India/Pakistan: Films continue to fall victim to threats and censorship
India’s Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) has refused to certify film ‘Lipstick Under My Burkha’, which revolves around the stories of four women, reported Hindustan Times on 23 February 2017.
The CBFC stated the reason for the denial was that: “The story is lady oriented, their fantasy above life. There are contanious [sic] sexual scenes, abusive words, audio pornography and a bit sensitive touch about one particular section of society, hence film refused under guidelines [sic].”
The film’s director Alankrita Shrivastava called the CBFC’s actions an “assault on women’s rights” and said she would fight for her film to be released in the country.
Shrivastava said in a statement:
I believe the decision to refuse certification to our film is an assault on women’s rights. For too long the popular narrative has perpetuated patriarchy by objectifying women or minimising their role in a narrative. So a film like ‘Lipstick Under My Burkha’, that challenges that dominant narrative is being attacked because it presents a female point of view. Do women not have the right of freedom of expression?
The film has won the Oxfam Award for Best Film on Gender Equality at the Mumbai Film Festival and the Spirit of Asia Prize at the Tokyo International Film Festival.
Far-right political party threatens film distributors
In January 2017, the Chhattisgarh wing in central India of far-right political party Shiv Sena sent a letter to film distributors warning them of “dire consequences” if they go ahead with the release of action crime thriller ‘Raess’, reported The Times of India on 29 January 2017.
Leading film distributor Akshaye Rathi took to Twitter, posted a photo of the letter and addressed the tweet to Aaditya Thackeray, the leader of the youth wing of the political party and son of the of the party’s leader.
Rathi told The Indian Express on 11 January 2017 that all distributors in Chhattisgarh state received the letter.
“It’s illegal to say that you will stall a film that has been certified by the CBFC for release. Also something needs to be done about this threat letter. We have informed the police about it,” Rathi said.
The film had first had some controversy in late 2016 for having a Pakistani actress in the cast. At the time, India banned Pakistani actors and technicians from working on Indian films as a response to deadly attacks over Kashmir in September 2016.
Bollywood film banned in Pakistan
However, in Pakistan, ‘Raees’ suffered more than threats, it was outright banned by Pakistan’s CBFC, reported BBC on 7 February 2017.
Though the CBFC did not give an official statement on the ban, an official told BBC that one reason for the ban was that the film “depicts Muslims as criminals and terrorists” and that some scenes were “offensive to a particular sect”.
Hollywood film suffers cuts in India
India’s CBFC made several cuts to Vin Diesel’s latest action film ‘xXx: The Return of Xander Cage’, including the removal of a suggestive bedroom scene that involves no nudity, the removal of particular swear words, including the word “baller”, and the removal of a scene where a woman is pouring liquor, reported Hindustan Times on 21 January 2017.
The last cut in particular has drawn controversy as the scene in question does not have a woman pouring alcohol, but rather cranberry juice and club soda. Additionally, the film makes it clear that its main character does not drink.
Censor board overturns decision on music video
On 25 January 2017, India’s Film Certification Appellate Tribunal (FCAT) overruled the CBFC’s directive to cut ten seconds from Friends of Linger’s music video ‘Miss You’, the band’s frontman Sharif Ranganekar wrote in The Wire on 30 January 2017.
The CBFC’s cut involved a ten-second scene they called “intimate” where two men are on a bed in shorts, though not engaging in any sexual activities, reported LGBTQ Nation on 3 February 2017.
The board gave the video an “A certificate”, meaning that it couldn’t be aired on television, but the FCAT revoked the certificate, calling the scene in question “intrinsic” to the story being told in the music video.
Ranganekar said the FCAT decision “in effect turned this tiny song into a moment that could be viewed as a shift in acceptance of ‘gay’ content in mainstream television”, explaining:
However small the shift might be, it could well be an indication of something bigger that many LGBTQs are hoping for. If we place this against the backdrop of hostility, hate, right-wing politics and the patiently-awaited Supreme Court verdict, the FCAT’s conclusion to overturn a CBFC order is not very small. It could be a precedent, a filmmaker out of Mumbai told me. Some gay activists felt the occasion should be celebrated and the song performed at gay parties.
The band’s frontman said he had to wait for four months for the appeal, but once it came for FCAT to review the video, the whole process took ten minutes.
Top photo: Section of ‘Lipstick Under My Burkha’ poster
» Twitter – 23 February 2017
Alankrita Shrivastava Twitter post
» Hindustan Times – 23 February 2017
Lipstick Under My Burkha: CBFC refuses to certify Prakash Jha’s film
» The Indian Express – 23 February 2017
CBFC denies certification to Prakash Jha’s ‘Lipstick Under My Burkha’ as it is ‘lady oriented’. Are you shocked already?
» Mumbai Mirror – 23 February 2017
CBFC refuses to certify Prakash Jha’s film ‘Lipstick Under My Burkha’
» The Indian Express – 9 February 2017
Sha Rukh Khan’s Raees banned in Pakistan for showing Muslims in ‘negative light’
» BBC – 7 February 2017
Pakistan bans Shah Rukh Khan film Raees
» The Guardian – 7 February 2017
Pakistan bans hit Bollywood film Raees
» The Wire – 30 January 2017
Film certification tribunal offers LGBT community a ray of hope
» The Times of India – 29 January 2017
Shiv Sena wing threatens distributor against screening Shah Rukh Khan’s ‘Raees’
» International Business Times – 22 January 2017
Indian censor board inexplicably cut Vin Diesel drinking soda in xXx reboot
» Hindustan Times – 21 January 2017
xXx: CBFC’s leaked list of cuts reveals they censored Vin Diesel drinking soda
» The Indian Express – 11 January 2017
Raees: Shiv Sena wants Shah Rukh Khan’s film banned in Chhattisgarh, issues threat letter
» Twitter – 10 January 2017
Akshaye Rathi Twitter post
More from Freemuse
» 18 November 2016: India: Film censorship board agrees to new film ratings
» 4 October 2016: India/Pakistan: Films, actors, tv shows banned amidst Kashmir tensions
» 23 August 2016: India: Artists struggle with censors over LGBT and other themes
» 13 July 2016: India: Film censorship continues unabated
» 16 June 2016: India: Film survives censor board controversy after court ruling
» 30 May 2016: India: Censors under fire
» 19 April 2016: India: Censor board bans own member’s movie
» 17 March 2016: Pakistan: Two Bollywood films banned
» 11 March 2016: India: Two superhero blockbusters suffer cuts
» 12 February 2016: India: Frustrations in film industry over censorship
» 21 January 2016: India: Censor board’s ‘truly epic cuts’ to American movie
» 26 November 2015: India: Pakistani actors banned in Maharashtra state
» 25 November 2015: India: Board censors James Bond kissing scenes
» 17 September 2015: Pakistan: Court dismissed petition Indian films
» 25 August 2015: Pakistan: Various Bollywood films banned
» 14 February 2015: India: Rift in censor board over list of ‘banned words’